For the Love of All Things Holy—Connection Is The Way
An (un)heretical Offering for the High Holy Season
I’m on someone’s “Naughty” “Needs Saving” list. Well, actually, a couple. I know this because my inbox tells me so. Every few weeks, like clockwork, I receive a forwarded meme or reel—a preacher shouting about sin, a bold-font Scripture slapped on a sunrise, or the classic ‘God can work even your foolishness for good' message. No personal note. No context. Just... sent.
Who decided passive-aggressiveness was the Lord’s work and added it to the Sunday School curriculum? And has anyone in the history of ever been truly saved by a cryptic “You’ve fallen short—like really short—but lucky for you, Jesus loves a project. Get your ass to church.” DM?
My most recent spiritual care package came from someone I haven’t interacted with in over a year—a season that, for the record, included going out on the proverbial limb and quitting my soul-sucking corporate job, moving, sending my firstborn out into the world to start her next chapter, and now teetering on the edge of sitting in my beautifully architectured nest all by my lonesome and wondering if I should be less more less more excited—all as a single parent. But sure, tell me more about how I’ve “fallen short.”
All this, of course, is news to my self-appointed strangers saviors, who are blissfully unaware that I grew up a faithful Presbyterian, hold a BA in Religious Studies, and could probably out-Jesus them in a game of Bible trivia. I’ve studied Jesus’ life—his radical inclusivity, his quiet humility, his habit of showing up for people. I’ve served Him and His children. So, if I’ve somehow—unknowingly—wandered off the path, it wasn’t for lack of a good map.
And then there’s my youngest, who has her own self-appointed “angel”—a woman who has taken it upon herself to guide my kid toward the light for the last couple of years. As if my daughter lives alone in a cave somewhere, utterly unsupervised, without an adult in her life who can (and is) guiding her in matters of faith. Just last month, this rep from The Lord’s PR Department sent a real-time DM during a sermon—as the preacher was preaching—urging my daughter to get herself to church because she was certain my kid needed to hear the message. Apparently, when God calls these days, it’s not through a burning bush—it’s through Instagram DMs from people who don’t even know you well enough to have your number.
It would almost be funny—if it weren’t so ironically tragic.
Jesus, the embodiment of connection, arrived quietly and humbly in the mess of a manger, surrounded by those who traveled to honor Him by being with Him.
He Himself never posted proclamations on temple walls or sent a guy on a donkey with a scroll. Can you imagine? ‘Good morning! Just a reminder that you’re failing me.’ – said literally never by Jesus.
Instead, He showed up.
He lived alongside people.
He sat. He listened. He asked questions.
He saw their soul and recognized their worth.
And then reflected it back to them.
And yet, somewhere along the way, the church seems to have lost sight of what matters—trading connection for conversion tactics, relationship for performance, and communion for control.
Without connection—real, human connection—we have no Jesus.
The people who make me feel seen and loved—who embody what I believe to be true about Jesus—don’t send me sermons they think I need. They lean in. They ask how I’m doing and then hold space for my honest answer. They speak kindly of me—especially when I’m not around. They support me without agenda. They’re curious about my story, my path, and my faith—not to correct it but to understand it, to understand me. And I try my damnedest to do the same for them.
Jesus met people precisely as they were, without pretense or pressure—not to change them in a day or “win” them over like some heavenly multi-level marketing scheme. He showed up as an equal, a human, a friend. The people who were changed by Him were changed by how He made them feel.
Seen.
Valued.
Loved.
If I’m honest, I have my own 'Needs Saving' list—names scribbled in invisible ink, people I’ve quietly sized up or tried to change. But what if I let go of those expectations and held out my hand instead?
The next couple of weeks will offer multiple opportunities to do exactly that. To slow down and sit across from beside one another. To ask questions and dig deeper. To listen and actually hear what’s being said and what isn’t. To meet people where they are and see them—really see them—for who they are.
What if that’s the most meaningful way to honor this season? To show up, humbly and humanly, for the people in front of us.
Maybe that’s where we’ll find Jesus waiting—in the quiet, in the mess, and in each other.




Erin, this essay is brilliant. Absolutely breathtaking in your style, the clarity of your voice, the strength of your message. I am with you. What I can say in a short space and time is this: I, too, have a postsecondary background in religious studies (as a minor to psychology, but I took a lot of extra theology on the side). I grew up Catholic (still am), and what I see about church-as-institution breaks my heart. Guts me.
Church is more political than personal. The clergy are more concerned with the collection basket and numbers attending than in outreach and accompaniment.
But I will tell you that I believe there are quiet saints walking amongst us. I have seen them. I know their love, because I have both witnessed and received it. My spiritual director challenges church-as-institution much the same way your essay has today. She says it's not enough to believe IN Jesus. We have to BELIEVE Jesus. We have to do what he did--go where he went, seek out the most destitute outcasts of society and live as their equals.
And ever since my sweet Sarah was born, I have felt drawn to live in this way. I think what it means to love, what it means to BE church today, is to first recognize that I am not all that different from those labeled the "worst" among us, and second, to befriend them, to get to know them, to stop long enough to notice and hear and see them. To stop the "othering," the us versus them, the superior versus inferior, concepts that divide people into containers too small for them.
So, I have hope. I guess the reason is that I know the only person I can control is myself. And though I am small and not powerful at all, I believe that what I choose to do with my life and how I choose to love others has a strong impact in my little community. And if more of us lived this way, then maybe we really could change the world.
Keep doing your worthy work.
Thank you for sharing your experiences in this realm, Erin! Growing up in the Catholic Church, one of the most memorable acts of Christ's love was during a weekend retreat when I was a young teen. I did not want to be there, and truthfully, I was being a bit of a shit. I remember whining about not being able to wash my hair (which is particularly bizarre to me now as I can go days camping and not think about it) and one of the guys heated water just so I could wash it in the sink. He was always kind, even when I didn't deserve it. THAT made an impact. All of the finger wagging throughout my life has not, and you can imagine how happy I was to learn that a friend was praying for me and my family during their church service to become Christians, or rather, their version of Christian. Um. Not needed, thank you very much. Your passive aggressive savior might do well to crack open the book they claim to love so much.